SH.SAM HODGSON
ARCHITECTURAL DESIGNER
← ALL ADVICE

New homes

Would a planted courtyard earn its place in your new home?

Five questions to help you decide whether a planted courtyard belongs in your new home, with a worked comparison of two hypothetical layouts.

A planted courtyard can be an appealing way to bring the garden closer to the middle of a home. But a green rectangle on a floor plan leaves plenty unanswered. I would want to know what the courtyard contributes to the rooms around it, what space it takes and how someone will look after it. These are the five questions I would bring to an early design conversation.

Key points

  • Identify the seats and everyday places that would benefit from a courtyard outlook.
  • Compare the courtyard with a layout that keeps the garden beside the house.
  • Test mature planting, maintenance access and the surrounding rooms before choosing a direction.

1. Which part of your day would the courtyard improve?

Give the space a specific job. Perhaps you want greenery beside the breakfast table, somewhere to sit alone or a planted outlook along an internal passage. Those purposes suggest different arrangements. A garden primarily enjoyed through glass still needs access, but it needn't accommodate the outdoor dining furniture as well.

Ask for views from the places where you actually pause. A standing view from the doorway can miss what someone seated at the table will see. The published California House design at Waikanae Beach uses internal gardens and courtyards to give rooms an outlook within the property. It is a useful reference for discussing which rooms should benefit.

2. What would the surrounding rooms give up?

Have the designer show the courtyard alongside a credible alternative without it. Keep the same household brief in both. Compare the dining setting, kitchen storage and route between rooms, rather than judging only the garden image.

I would be cautious about a courtyard that leaves every adjoining room slightly awkward. It may be worth changing its shape or moving it to the edge of the building, where it can open into the wider garden.

  • Draw the furniture in both options.
  • Mark any extra passage needed to get around the courtyard.
  • Identify which indoor compromise you would actually accept.

3. What happens when the planting grows?

Ask for the planting to be shown at its intended mature size as well as on moving day. MBIE's planting and landscaping guidance recommends considering fully grown plants and summer and winter sun angles. A small courtyard makes that conversation especially relevant: the planting and the surrounding walls need to be considered together.

I would ask a landscape designer which plants suit the actual light, soil and moisture conditions. Then check the view from inside again. Does the planting still give you the outlook you wanted, and what pruning would be needed to keep it that way?

  • Show the building's shadows, not just a sunny illustration.
  • Agree whether seasonal leaf loss suits the intended outlook.

4. How will you get the gardening done?

Trace a bag of compost into the courtyard and a load of prunings back out. If everything travels through the dining room, decide whether that is acceptable before settling the openings. Include reaching the glass to clean it and getting to the planting without trampling it.

Ask the building and landscape designers to explain the proposed drainage, planting depths and maintenance access together. These need project-specific answers. A planted space should come with a workable care plan, including who will do the work.

5. Does it still win when you compare complete layouts?

Consider a hypothetical couple planning a new home. They want a leafy breakfast outlook and a generous dining table. Option A places an enclosed courtyard between the kitchen and dining area. Once their table and chairs are drawn, the route around the courtyard squeezes the space behind the seats.

Option B places a planted recess beside the dining window, open to the garden along one side. The couple keep their breakfast outlook and the gardener can approach from outside. They give up the enclosed courtyard atmosphere. For this hypothetical brief, I would develop option B, then check its planting conditions and detailing with the team.

Your priorities might favour the enclosed version. Bring both the quality you want and the compromise you dislike to a conversation. If you would like help exploring that balance, we can discuss your site and what a useful first design comparison would show.

Sources and further reading

Source information checked 19 November 2026 at 9:30 am GMT+13. Rules may change; check the linked official guidance for your project.

ABOUT THE AUTHOR

Sam Hodgson

I’m the Founder, Director and Owner of Modal Architecture. I’m based in Auckland, spend one week each month with our Wellington team and regularly work in Queenstown.

More about me

This content is prepared with assistance from artificial intelligence tools and published under the authorship of Sam Hodgson.

Bring the question to your own project.

If this has helped you identify something you would like to explore, let’s talk about it.

Discuss your ideas for a new home