SH.SAM HODGSON
ARCHITECTURAL DESIGNER
← ALL ADVICE

Sites & places

Where should an upstairs window face when the neighbours are close?

Five questions to help you position an upstairs window beside neighbouring homes, with a worked comparison of window and desk arrangements.

A window can look perfectly balanced on an elevation and feel awkward from the chair behind it. If the natural place to look up from your desk is straight into the neighbour's bedroom, I would revisit the arrangement before choosing curtains. Designing beside other homes means finding a comfortable relationship between the rooms, not just fitting each building inside its boundary.

Key points

  • Draw the view from the places people will actually sit and stand.
  • Compare window position and room layout together before adding screening.
  • Keep daylight, outlook and privacy as separate questions so one solution is not assumed to answer everything.

1. What would you be looking at for most of the day?

Start with the activity inside your room. A landing window passed briefly and a study window beside an all-day desk deserve different conversations. Mark the desk, bed or favourite chair, then ask what falls naturally into view from there.

Use a plan for the sideways relationship and a section for the difference in levels. Include the neighbouring window or outdoor area that concerns you. Label anything that has been estimated, and arrange appropriate measurements rather than treating a guessed model as fact.

  • Check seated and standing views.
  • Look diagonally as well as straight ahead.
  • Consider the view back into your room.

2. Does the view need to come from that wall?

Imagine a hypothetical upstairs study with a side window opposite a neighbour's bedroom. The first layout puts the desk beneath that window. The household wants a pleasant outlook while working, but would probably keep the blind down.

I would compare a second arrangement: move the desk towards the garden end of the room and test an opening in that end wall. Retain a smaller or higher side opening only if it has a useful role. The comparison needs to show the furniture, usable wall space and views from both homes. Simply shifting the desk while leaving the same direct view through the room may achieve very little.

  • What outlook would the alternative actually offer?
  • Would the new desk position obstruct the door or storage?
  • What would need checking about daylight and ventilation?

3. Are you asking one window to do every job?

Daylight, a view outside and an opening for air are different parts of the brief. I would ask the designer to explain how each option addresses them, rather than assume a higher window is an automatic replacement for the original.

California House offers a useful design reference: its published description explains how internal gardens provide outlook while clerestory windows and skylights introduce daylight from above. That does not make its arrangement right for this hypothetical study. It shows why the source of light and the direction of the main view can be considered separately.

4. What would a screen take away as well as conceal?

MBIE's exterior-design guidance identifies window design, screens and vegetation as ways to address neighbouring privacy. I would test any screen from inside the room before accepting how it looks outside.

In our study example, a side screen might interrupt the unwanted diagonal view while retaining a garden outlook. It might also make the desk feel boxed in. Show both possibilities. If planting is proposed, ask what provides privacy before it grows and who will maintain it. Do not base the arrangement on someone else's tree staying forever.

  • Check the remaining outlook from the chair.
  • Show the opening window in use.
  • Ask how the screen and glass will be reached for cleaning.

5. Could you explain the preferred option from both sides?

Return to the two study layouts and write a sentence for each household: what the room gains, and what changes next door. In this hypothetical comparison, I would favour the garden-facing arrangement if it gives a worthwhile outlook and a workable room without creating another uncomfortable view. If it does not, keep testing.

Ask your designer or planner to check the property-specific requirements alongside this exercise. A considerate-looking sketch is not a compliance assessment.

If a neighbouring window is making your own plans feel constrained, bring the site details and your room priorities to a conversation with Modal Architecture. We can discuss which alternatives are worth drawing before you commit to the opening.

Sources and further reading

Source information checked 21 November 2026 at 9:30 am GMT+13. Rules may change; check the linked official guidance for your project.

ABOUT THE AUTHOR

Sam Hodgson

I’m the Founder, Director and Owner of Modal Architecture. I’m based in Auckland, spend one week each month with our Wellington team and regularly work in Queenstown.

More about me

This content is prepared with assistance from artificial intelligence tools and published under the authorship of Sam Hodgson.

Bring the question to your own project.

If this has helped you identify something you would like to explore, let’s talk about it.

Talk about the section you’re considering