Renovations
Does your kitchen need a walk-in pantry? Five questions before you move a wall
The most useful shelf in the house might be the one you can see from the breakfast table.
Compare a walk-in pantry with a cupboard wall by testing what you store, where you use it and what the dining room would give up.
Imagine a family whose cereal lives on top of the fridge while the pantry is full of serving dishes. They’d like a walk-in pantry and could borrow a corner of the dining room to make one. I’d put that option on paper. Then I’d draw another version with the dining room intact. Here’s how I’d work through the choice in this hypothetical kitchen.
Key points
- Empty one troublesome cupboard and sort its contents by where you use them.
- Draw the pantry shelves and the floor you need to stand on before comparing layouts.
- Test the proposed storage with your actual grocery shop, breakfast things and largest serving dish.
1. What actually needs more space?
The family empties the pantry onto the table. There’s plenty of food, but the awkward pieces are a cake stand, a stockpot and a platter too long for the cupboard door to shut. Extra shelves at the same depth would leave the platter on the fridge again. I’d trace the platter on paper and take that outline to the design meeting. It gives the designer a particular problem to solve.
- Group what you use every morning separately from things you fetch for a crowd.
- Set aside anything that belongs elsewhere before sizing new kitchen storage around it.
2. Do you want to store things in there or work in there?
These are different briefs. If the family wants to keep the mixer out of sight, a shelf might do. If they want to bake in the pantry, they need somewhere for the mixing bowl, ingredients and tray at the same time. In our example, the person who bakes likes working at the kitchen bench with the window open. A cupboard for the mixer beside that bench would suit them better than a second worktop in a room they’d rather leave.
3. What does the dining room lose?
I’d mark the proposed pantry wall on the dining room floor with tape. For this family, dinner still fits. The surprise comes on Sunday, when they extend the table and the person at the end can’t get out without asking someone else to move. They could turn the table, but that would take away the window seat they use for breakfast. That seat now has a vote in the kitchen layout.
The Ben Lomond renovation shows the kitchen, dining room and entrance considered together on the lower floor.
See the kitchen and dining arrangement at Alpine Retreat4. Can you see what you’ve already bought?
In the alternative sketch, the designer puts a cupboard wall where the family’s deep pantry stands now. Tall cupboard fronts can look tidy in either scheme. What matters is what happens behind them. Try drawing the shelves from the front, then from above, and placing a second tin behind the first. Can you spot that you’ve got tomatoes without unloading the chickpeas? Repeat the exercise for a big bag of rice. It might earn a deep drawer even if the tins suit shallow shelves.
- Mark a home for unopened packets so they don’t bury the ones already in use.
- Show where the grocery bags will sit while you put the shopping away.
Compare the room layouts at concept stage, then develop the cupboard interiors once you know which arrangement you want.
Explore the design stages5. What would make the walk-in worth keeping?
For this family the answer would be a second place to cook. They don’t want one. Their revised brief keeps the dining room, puts cereal and bowls together at the breakfast end of the kitchen, and gives the platter an upright slot beside the serving bench. Someone who regularly cooks alongside another person might make the opposite choice, especially if a second workspace lets both finish a dish without swapping places.
If you’re undecided, bring both sketches and a photo of the cupboard you dread opening. I’d be happy to look at what each option does for your kitchen, and what it asks of the room next door.
This is a starting point if you’d like help weighing a cabinetry change against altering the rooms themselves.
Renovation design servicesSources and further reading
Source information checked 13 November 2026 at 2:35 pm GMT+13. Rules may change; check the linked official guidance for your project.
Bring the question to your own project.
If this has helped you identify something you would like to explore, let’s talk about it.
Discuss your renovation with Sam