SH.SAM HODGSON
ARCHITECTURAL DESIGNER
← ALL ADVICE

Renovations

Renovating in stages: five questions before you fit something permanent

Use a dining room and a possible garden extension to test which improvements to make now, which to keep movable and which can wait.

Imagine spending good money on a window seat, enjoying it for a couple of summers, then pulling it out because it sits exactly where you want a doorway to the garden. The seat wasn’t a bad idea. The trouble was treating that wall as settled when the rest of the house was still up for discussion. If you’re renovating in stages, I’d ask these five questions before ordering anything made to fit.

Key points

  • Mark the parts of the room that change between your possible layouts before ordering fitted furniture.
  • Try the proposed layout with loose furniture and use it during an ordinary meal.
  • Ask for the cost of keeping, moving or removing an item before calling it reusable.

1. What do you need the room to do this winter?

Take a hypothetical family with a cramped dining room and a possible extension off the back of the house. Their immediate complaint is quite specific: whoever sits nearest the garden has to get up every time someone takes a plate through to the kitchen. They’ve asked for a built-in bench under the rear window. Before drawing one, I’d put the complaint at the top of the brief. That leaves us free to solve it by turning the table, changing the seating or moving the crockery, as well as by building something.

2. Which bit of the plan changes its job?

Sketch the dining room twice at the same scale. On one copy, keep the house as it is. On the other, show the extension you might want. In this example the rear window becomes a wide opening, but the inside wall beside the kitchen stays put. Lay one sketch over the other. Now you can see why a window seat and a dresser against the inside wall are very different bets, even if both fit beautifully today.

  • Circle the wall or opening that changes.
  • Draw the table and the chairs pulled out on both copies.

3. Can you try the idea over dinner?

Borrow a freestanding bench, or use chairs to mark its ends, and turn the table the way it would sit after the change. Have someone carry a serving dish from the kitchen while everyone else stays seated. Then try getting out from the middle of the bench. Those are different movements. A layout that makes serving easier might leave a child shuffling past two adults to leave the table. Try the same meal with the bench on the inside wall before deciding which version deserves a drawing.

4. What would moving it actually involve?

‘We can reuse it later’ is easy to say about a seat. It’s less convincing if the seat is scribed to a crooked wall, the skirting stops at either end and the floor finish stops at its feet. Ask the joiner to talk you through lifting it out and using it in the second layout. Ask the builder what would be left behind. When comparing options, give both people the same sketches so one price doesn’t quietly leave out making good.

  • List what travels with the seat, including any storage underneath.
  • List what stays in the room and would need finishing after removal.

5. What would make you choose the fitted version?

For this family, suppose the loose bench on the inside wall solves the serving problem and everyone can get out comfortably. I’d keep it there and leave the window alone. If they later drop the extension and still want a seat overlooking the garden, the case for fitting one changes. They can choose it for the house they intend to keep, rather than pay now for a guess about the doorway.

If you’re weighing up a similar purchase, bring the two sketches and the dimensions of the furniture you already own. I’m happy to help you work out which changes are useful whichever way the renovation goes.

Sources and further reading

Source information checked 16 November 2026 at 9:28 am GMT+13. Rules may change; check the linked official guidance for your project.

ABOUT THE AUTHOR

Sam Hodgson

I’m the Founder, Director and Owner of Modal Architecture. I’m based in Auckland, spend one week each month with our Wellington team and regularly work in Queenstown.

More about me

This content is prepared with assistance from artificial intelligence tools and published under the authorship of Sam Hodgson.

Bring the question to your own project.

If this has helped you identify something you would like to explore, let’s talk about it.

Discuss your renovation with Sam